Articles · 20 November 2026 · Paulina Grzegorzek
How to tell if your email campaign is working
After a few weeks of sending, the same question always comes up: is this actually working? The number of emails sent says little, and open rates have become less and less reliable in recent years. It is worth looking at a few other numbers and recording them in one place from the very start.
Opens are no longer a good measure
Some email clients download the images in a message automatically, so an email looks opened even though nobody has read it. Others block tracking altogether. The open rate can therefore be seventy or ten per cent regardless of what is really happening on the other side.
Treat opens as a warning signal at most. If they suddenly drop to almost zero, your emails have probably started landing in spam.
Reply rate, broken down
The most important number to start with is the reply rate: how many people replied relative to the number of people you wrote to. Not relative to the number of emails, because with a three-message sequence the result would be artificially low.
It is a good idea to split replies into three groups straight away: interested; declines and “not now”; and requests not to be contacted. A ten per cent reply rate where most replies say “please remove me” is a completely different campaign from five per cent where half are questions about your offer.
Enquiries and meetings
In the end, what counts is how many conversations you managed to start. That is why, alongside replies, it is worth tracking the number of enquiries, meaning cases where someone asks for a quote, materials or details, and the number of meetings booked.
If for several weeks there are replies but no enquiries, the problem usually lies in the choice of companies or in the proposition itself, not in the wording of the email. In that case it is better to go back to the question of who you are writing to and why than to keep polishing sentences.
Unsubscribes and bounced emails
The share of people asking not to be contacted and of emails that bounce as undelivered tells you about the quality of the list. A lot of bounces means out-of-date addresses and a risk that future emails will start landing in spam. A lot of unsubscribes is a sign that the list is too broad or the reason for getting in touch is not convincing.
Every request not to be contacted must be recorded immediately and excluded from future sends, including those run by other salespeople. This is a legal requirement, not just good practice.
Results by list, not for the whole campaign
An average for the whole campaign hides the most interesting things. The same message can work well in logistics and not at all in manufacturing. That is why it pays to track results separately for each list, meaning a group of companies with a similar profile, and compare them side by side: number of companies, replies, enquiries, meetings and unsubscribes.
After a month it is usually clear which lists to develop and which to stop writing to. That is far more valuable than a single overall reply rate.
How long to give a campaign
The first replies usually arrive within a few days of the first email, but many only come after the second or third message in the sequence. So draw conclusions once the whole sequence for a given list has finished, not after the first week.
To begin with, one well-chosen list of a few dozen companies is enough. It will show whether the direction makes sense before more time is put into the campaign.
One place for the numbers
The most time is lost piecing together numbers from several tools before a meeting. If emails sent, replies and meetings are recorded automatically in the CRM and a dashboard shows them by list, a discussion about the campaign takes a few minutes and is about decisions, not about where to find the data.